Which external hard drive is better, seagate or wd elements, and why. Why is my wd my book 3tb hard drive not showing up. Now that the prices have come down, the wd 4tb is really the product you want if you need that much space. Amazons choice for western digital 3tb wd purple 3tb surveillance hard drive 5400 rpm class, sata 6 gbs, 64 mb cache, 3. The 8 tb version of the western digital my book offers reliability, fast. Other than the new design, the drive doesnt have much to elevate it above others. Today, we will be looking at the 8tb hard drive for each. Improve pc performance when your internal hard drive is almost full your pc slows down. New western digital hard drive controller board 4061775200 rev aa for wd my book essential elements 1tb, 2tb, 3tb, 4tb, 5tb, 6tb usb 3. Western digital new hard drive controller board 4061775200 rev. Jan 22, 2015 the western digital red 3tb drives annual failure rate of 7. It includes a free trial of wd smartware pro backup software for local and cloud backup. Western digital elements 3tb external drive pc talk. So there is these two extenal drives on the wd site.
My book vs elements desktop external drives for pc wd. Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as wd my book or wd my passport wireless pro. But for the 3tb versions, are the physical drives inside the same. When looking at the best external hard drive picks, the 3tb capacity doesnt come up much. Wd unveiled today its latest desktop external hard drive the wd my book. Seagate drives have by far the highest rate of failure of any hard drive manufacturer. We are going to look at how the wd elements vs my book desktop.
Based on 7,843 user benchmarks for the wd elements and the my book 1140, we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 639 usbs. If your product is not listed above, please visit the product page. Which external hard drive is better, seagate or wd. I honestly doubt theres a difference as theyre relatively the same price usually. Equipped with wd backup software for windows and apple time machine compatibility for mac, the my book desktop hard drive can back up your photos, videos. Find low everyday prices and buy online for delivery or instore pickup.
It has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as wd my book or wd my passport for mac. Aug 18, 2017 the my passport ultra drive is a portable hdd that features usb 3. Im no hd expert, so i was hoping to get some opinions about these two drives. Aa for wd my book essential elements 1tb 2tb 3tb 4tb 5tb. Western digital elements desktop vs western digital my book. Western digital has been selling these external storage devices with the highest storage capacity drives in their class for some time now the 3. Performance benchmarks western digital my book 8tb and. Buy wd 3tb my book desktop external hard drive usb 3. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd. As well talk about in a minute, 3tb is a bit of a sore spot for most hard drives, forcing many. The wd my passport ultra is a portable drive thats powered by your computer or console over a single usb cable and provides plenty of storage for backup, data transportation or simply just expanding the capacity of a system whos internal drive has become stuffed to the brim.
Oct 11, 2016 wd unveiled today its latest desktop external hard drive the wd my book. I checked the official website i read the product overview and user. Hey guys, i lucked out recently and bought cheaply a western digital my book 3tb external hard drive. I have the western digital 2tb, then got the wd 3tb, and more recently got the wd 4tb. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd 4tb my book desktop usb 3. Or can also be used for a systemlevel backup, which includes the operating system and applications. The wd 6tb my book desktop contains a wd60ezrz drive a western digital blue, 3. Why you should buy 4tb hard drives and skip the 3tb ones. I bought the seagate barracuda 3tb and it shows as 746gb on my windows vista sp2 32bit in gpt mode. Shop for wd red 3tb nas hard disk drive at best buy. Western digital my book 3tb what are the rps speeds.
The sleek design features up to 3tb capacity plus wd quality and reliability. The new wd my book is both smaller and uses very different design than the older model, as it now sports angled corners compared to the rounded front panel used before. External hard drive western digital my book 3tb on see all the product information. Which is rarely useful unless you backing up and mirroring your data. The 2tb elements external desktop hard disk drive from western digital is an external hard drive designed to fit easily onto your desktop. The western digital red 3tb drives annual failure rate of 7. You can choose from a 3tb, 4tb, 6tb, 8tb, 10tb, 12tb, and a 14tb. In reply to bee6 sep 15, 2011 hi i have several external drives that i use to backup my data and my latest acquisition is the 3tb wd element in addition to 2 1gb elements, a 500 gb wd my passport essential and several smaller seagate go drives. Oct 15, 2015 wd currently has two external desktop drive models, the my book and the elements desktop. A 3tb my book and now a 6tb elements, they are equaly good, both with 3. Western digital my book 8tb and my passport 4tb external hdds.
Western digital elements 3tb external drive pc talk forum. Answer the my book drive can be used to backup your files, such as documents, pictures, movies, etc. The mypassport 1tb died within a year because the usb socket on the drive itself came off. I didnt know if both product lines use the same exact drive or is the. The best external hard drives you can buy in 2020 the telegraph. Oct 11, 2016 here, the new wd my book recorded a pcmark score of 2552 with a bandwidth of 10. What is the difference between wd elements and wd passport.
Western digital my book 8tb and my passport 4tb external. Seagate expansion or wd mybook for external hard drive. We delete comments that violate our policy, which we encourage you to read. Wd currently has two external desktop drive models, the my book and the elements desktop. The 3tb and 4tb capacities are better suited with the western digital my book, which starts at 3tb and goes up to 20tb. Wd 12tb elements desktop external hard drive usb 3. The aim of the article is to help you choose the best one for you, whether you are replacing an old hard drive, or buying a new, preferably before something goes wrong. Conclusion overall, wds new my book is a solid choice for the general consumer looking for a solution to back up a large amount of data, such images of their entire computer and large media files, leveraging a relatively large. All four mybooks are still alive and kicking 500gb, 2tb, 3tb, 4tb, which ive had for 5, 4, 2, and 1 years respectively. Western digital elements desktop vs western digital my. I do have a 3tb seagate though since the external update and its worked as expected. The wd elements desktop hard drive and the wd my book desktop hard drive come with various storage capacities. Have an old wd 1tb passport that has had zero issues and works great, same with all my wd hds.
The basic differences compared to elements are as follows. As to fixing this youll need to get a file recover app to hopefully knit back together the directory services which are corrupted on the disk. I understand the my book has included software and supports encryption. We highlight the best usb flash drive in terms of balanced performance and value for money using current prices. Nov 05, 2014 wd elements, wd my book vs my cloud festplatte gehause. I have lost data from a 3tb that was not backed up, and it was a disaster. The next time its best to shutdown the computer so it forces the saving of the files. If anyone else is looking at buying one of these, jb hifi. Looking at western digitals warranty information page i see this.
I want to manually copy all my audiobooks on my windows pc to an external hard drive. What is the difference in a 3tb my book versus elements external hard drive. Well regardless whether storage can be expanded or not, i went ahead an bought western digital 2tb my book mirror edition. Now ive copied all the stuff i want on it and now im wondering if all that stuff is already on the other hard drive or do i have to do some sort of a backup to have the mirror image of one drive on another drive. This generation has 8tb, 6tb, 4tb and 3tb single drive models. They are built to be the cheapest, and their low quality build shows in their desinlgns. Wd my book is a very popular and one of the more expensive options. Ive setup my wd my book mirror edition 2tb drive to raid 1. In open air, spin and seek noise seems to be better than a nowneighbouring seagate drive, appearing to be very similar to some of my older wd green drives which i think these newer blue drives have largely.
Designed to meet wds demanding requirements for durability, shock tolerance, and longterm reliability, we back up pun intended. The backup setup depends on whether you use the wd smartware or the acronis true image wd edition. You get a wd smart ware pro which is a nice utility for syncing you data. Western digitals 4 tb elements is about as fast as our top pick, but its. Designed for consumers and professionals on the go who to store large amounts of data, the new my passport ultra is available in a maximum capacity of 4tb.
Wd my book essentials 3tb posted in external hardware. I have asked this problem at seagate forum and the one guy who replied didnt know how to solve it. This article is going to discuss the differences between the wd elements vs my passport. The wd mybook duo range builds up from 3 tb to 24 tb, with superfast read and write speeds of around 360 mb per second. Its likely the actual actual drives on these two are the sameif the. Wd 14tb elements desktop external hard drive usb 3. The compact design offers up to 14tb capacity, making wd elements desktop storage the ideal solution for easy, addon storage of all your important photos, music, videos and files. There is also a difference in cost and maximum size.
1628 74 1369 800 745 784 336 266 713 979 244 1418 47 694 1418 1021 1533 247 1601 403 1277 1370 1070 774 60 697 1015 1108 658 56